005 · The Findings

What we found.

122 Investment Policy Statements, scored 1–5 against the rubric across 14 domains. No plan is named here and none can be worked out: plans appear once, as opaque numbers, in a single list. Everything else is a distribution.

122
plans scored
3.71
median overall
3.65
mean overall
1.99–4.50
range

How the universe scores

Overall score, 16 bins of 0.25. The rust line is the median.

median · 3.71 1 2 3 4 5 Excellent 1 Strong 82 Adequate 37 Weak 2 Deficient 0

Top overall

The only place a plan is labelled — and only with a number that means nothing else on this site.

PlanOverall
Plan 394.50
Plan 1174.44
Plan 1374.33
Plan 1134.29
Plan 584.27
Plan 164.25
Plan 764.25
Plan 1094.23
Plan 1364.21
Plan 1504.19

By domain

Mean score per rubric domain. Rust bars are core domains (they drive the overall score); grey are optional.

Scope, Purpose & Coverage 4.42 Investment Objectives 3.58 Investment Philosophy 3.47 Risk Tolerance & Risk Philosophy 3.41 Time Horizon & Constraints 3.10 Liquidity & Cash Flow Management 2.71 Spending / Distribution Policy 2.23 Strategic Asset Allocation 4.32 Rebalancing Policy 3.55 Performance Measurement & Benchmarks 3.84 Governance & Decision-Making 4.48 Monitoring, Reporting & Review 4.23 Implementation & Manager Oversight 3.98 Responsible Investment / ESG 2.21

By category

Category means average every domain in the category, optional ones included — so they aren't directly comparable to the overall score.

Governance & Oversight 4.35 Objectives Clarity 3.82 Risk Framework 3.07 Portfolio Design 3.37 Implementation and Oversight 3.91 Responsible Investing/ESG 2.21

Most common critical gaps

65 of 122 plans (53.28%) have at least one domain flagged as a critical gap.

DomainPlansShare
Spending / Distribution Policy5847.54%
Liquidity & Cash Flow Management2218.03%
Rebalancing Policy64.92%
Time Horizon & Constraints54.1%
Monitoring, Reporting & Review32.46%
Performance Measurement & Benchmarks32.46%
Implementation & Manager Oversight10.82%
Investment Objectives10.82%
Risk Tolerance & Risk Philosophy10.82%
Strategic Asset Allocation10.82%

By lens

Each domain is scored through four lenses; this is the mean of every lens score in the universe.

Presence & clarity 3.66 Quantification & enforceability 2.98 Consistency & structure 4.03 Governance & process 3.51

Recent rewrites vs the universe

64 plans adopted or revised their IPS in the last twelve months. Their median is 3.81 against the universe's 3.71. Distribution only — no rows.

recent median · 3.81 1 2 3 4 5